Cast
- Peter Pan - Miles Callisto (Miles from Tomorrowland)
- Wendy Darling - Charity Bazaar (Histeria!)
- Tinker Bell - Rosetta (Disney Fairies)
- John Darling - Taran (The Black Cauldron)
- Michael Darling - Loud Kiddington (Histeria!)
- Captain Hook - Gaston (Beauty and the Beast; 1991)
- Mr. Smee - LeFou (Beauty and the Beast; 1991)
- Tick-Tock Crocodile - Lumpjaw (Fun and Fancy Free)
- Lost Boys Played By:
- Slightly - Mowgli (The Jungle Book; 1967)
- Twins - Beanstalk Jack and Humpty Dumpty (Goldie & Bear)
- Cubby - Cody (The Rescuers Down Under)
- Nibs - Prince James (Sofia the First)
- Tootles - Pinocchio
- The Mermaids Played By:
- Red Haired Mermaid - Anna (Frozen)
- Other Red Haired Mermaid - Elsa (Frozen)
- Yellow Haired Mermaid - Belle (Beauty and the Beast; 1991)
- Other Yellow Haired Mermaid - Vanessa Bloome (Bee Movie)
- Black Haired Mermaid - Gwen (Total Drama)
- Other Black Haired Mermaid - Lindsay (Total Drama)
- Tiger Lily - Little Red Riding Hood (Goldie & Bear)
- Indian Chief - Maurice (Beauty and the Beast; 1991)
- Nana - Duchess (The Aristocats)
- George Darling - Flynn Rider (Eugene Fitzherbert) (Tangled)
- Mary Darling - Rapunzel (Tangled)