Penny Proud, nicknamed The Jazz Singer, was invited to a dinner party in the 1920s at an Estate owned by Joey Graceffa. She accuses Joey of being in league with The Evil, and votes him in to play Perverse Games alongside Lele Pons. When Joey is given the Death Journal and has to choose who to betray, he chooses GloZell, which causes her to choke on and vomit her own blood, thus killing her. Sometime after this, her soul is collected by The Collector and stored in the Jar of Souls. Her soul is later freed by Joey, Bretman Rock, and Colleen Ballinger.